Antibody response induced by the BNT162b2 mRNA COVID-19 vaccine in a cohort of health-care workers, with or without prior SARS-CoV-2 infection: a prospective study

Buonfrate, Dora; Piubelli, Chiara; Gobbi, Federico; Martini, Davide; Bertoli, Giulia; Ursini, Tamara; Moro, Lucia; Ronzoni, Niccolò; Angheben, Andrea; Rodari, Paola; Cardellino, Chiara; Tamarozzi, Francesca; Tais, Stefano; Rizzi, Eleonora; Degani, Monica; Deiana, Michela; Prato, Marco; Silva, Ronaldo; Bisoffi, Zeno

OBJECTIVES: We assessed the antibody response to BNT162b2 mRNA COVID-19 vaccine in a cohort of health care workers (HCW), comparing subjects with previous SARS-CoV-2 infection and naïve subjects. METHODS: HCW were tested at T0 (day of first dose), T1 (day of second dose), and T2 (2-3 weeks after) for IgG anti nucleocapside protein, IgM anti spike protein and IgG anti receptor binding domain (IgG-RBD-S). The antibody response was compared between 4 main groups: A) Subjects with previous infection and positive antibodies at baseline; B) subjects with same history but negative antibodies; C) subjects with no infection history but positive antibodies; D) naïve subjects. Repeated measures analysis was used to compare results over time points. RESULTS: 1,935 HCW were included. Median IgG-RBD-S titre was significantly higher for group A (232 subjects) than for group B (56 subjects) both at T1 (A: 22,763 AU/mL, IQR 14,222-37,204; B: 1,373 AU/mL, IQR 783-3,078, p=0.0003) and T2 (A: 30,765 AU/mL, IQR 19,841-42,813; B:13,171 AU/mL, IQR 2,324-22,688, p=0.0038) and for group D (1563 subjects): 796 AU/mL, IQR 379-1,510 at T1; 15,494 AU/mL, IQR 9,122-23,916 at T2, p<0.0001 both timepoints. T1 values of group A were also significantly higher than T2 values of group D (p<0.0001). Presence of symptoms, younger age and female gender were associated with stronger antibody response. HCW infected in March showed a significantly stronger response (T1: 35,324 AU/mL, IQR 22,003-44,531; T2: 37,648 AU/mL, IQR 27,088-50,451) than those infected in November (T1: 18,499 AU/mL, IQR 11,492-27,283; T2: 23,210 AU/mL, IQR 18,074-36,086): p<0.0001, both timepoints. CONCLUSIONS: Subjects with past COVID-19 infection had a strong antibody response after one single vaccine shot. A single dose might be sufficient for this group, regardless the time elapsed since infection, however the clinical correlation with antibody response needs to be studied.