Integrated analyses of single-cell atlases reveal age, gender, and smoking status associations with cell type-specific expression of mediators of SARS-CoV-2 viral entry and highlights inflammatory programs in putative target cells

Christoph Muus; Malte D Luecken; Gokcen Eraslan; Avinash Waghray; Graham Heimberg; Lisa Sikkema; Yoshihiko Kobayashi; Eeshit Dhaval Vaishnav; Ayshwarya Subramanian; Christopher Smillie; Karthik Jagadeesh; Elizabeth Thu Duong; Evgenij Fiskin; Elena Torlai Triglia; Christophe Becavin; Meshal Ansari; Peiwen Cai; Brian Lin; Justin Buchanan; Sijia Chen; Jian Shu; Adam L Haber; Hattie Chung; Daniel T Montoro; Taylor Adams; Hananeh Aliee; Samuel J Allon; Zaneta Andrusivova; Ilias Angelidis; Orr Ashenberg; Kevin Bassler; Christophe Becavin; Inbal Benhar; Joseph Bergenstrahle; Ludvig Bergenstrahle; Liam Bolt; Emelie Braun; Linh T Bui; Mark Chaffin; Evgeny Chichelnitskiy; Joshua Chiou; Thomas M Conlon; Michael S Cuoco; Marie Deprez; David S Fischer; Astrid Gillich; Joshua Gould; Minzhe Guo; Austin J Gutierrez; Arun C Habermann; Tyler Harvey; Peng He; Xiaomeng Hou; Lijuan Hu; Alok Jaiswal; Peiyong Jiang; Theodoros Kapellos; Christin S Kuo; Ludvig Larsson; Michael A Leney-Greene; Kyungtae Lim; Monika Litvinukova; Ji Lu; Leif S Ludwig; Wendy Luo; Henrike Maatz; Elo Maddissoon; Lira Mamanova; Kasidet Manakongtreecheep; Charles-Hugo Marquette; Ian Mbano; Alexi M McAdams; Ross J Metzger; Ahmad N Nabhan; Sarah K Nyquist; Jose Ordovas-Montanes; Lolita Penland; Olivier B Poirion; Segio Poli; CanCan Qi; Daniel Reichart; Ivan Rosas; Jonas Schupp; Rahul Sinha; Rene V Sit; Kamil Slowikowski; Michal Slyper; Neal Smith; Alex Sountoulidis; Maximilian Strunz; Dawei Sun; Carlos Talavera-Lopez; Peng Tan; Jessica Tantivit; Kyle J Travaglini; Nathan R Tucker; Katherine Vernon; Marc H Wadsworth; Julia Waldman; Xiuting Wang; Wenjun Yan; Ali Onder Yildirim; William Zhao; Carly G K Ziegler; Aviv Regev

A limitation of our expression model is that each cell is treated as an independent observation. Thus, the significance of association with traits such as sex, age, and smoking status may show inflated p-values, especially where the associations are determined from few donors. In this case, the variation between cells from a single donor dominates the variation between donors, background variation is underestimated and effect significance can be overestimated. Aggregating many datasets allows us to counteract this effect, yet p-value inflation may occur in cell types that are not as commonly shared across datasets. Our main conclusions are drawn on airway epithelial and AT2 cells, which are distributed widely across datasets and are modeled on the basis of many donors. Furthermore, we have confirmed significant associations by pseudo-bulk analysis and by holding out datasets. This confirmation ensures that associations are consistent when only considering donor variation, and we are aware if these associations are dataset dependent (often when one dataset is a particularly major source of a given cell type). Models that account for both single-cell count distributions, and population structure in the data have the potential to improve future meta-analyses across single-cell atlases.