Effectiveness of different types of mask in aerosol dispersion in SARS-CoV-2 infection

Tanisali, Gokhan; Sozak, Ahmet; Bulut, Abdul Samet; Sander, Tolga Ziya; Dogan, Ozlem; Dağ, Çağdaş; Gönen, Mehmet; Can, Fusun; DeMirci, Hasan; Ergonul, Onder

OBJECTIVE: To compare the effectiveness of different mask types in limiting the dispersal of coughed air. METHOD: The Schlieren method with a single curved mirror was used in this study. Coughed air has a slightly higher temperature than ambient air, which generates a refractive index gradient. A curved mirror with a radius of curvature of 10 m and a diameter of 60 cm was used. The spread of the cough wavefront was investigated among five subjects wearing: (1) no mask; (2) a single surgical mask; (3) a double surgical mask; (4) a cloth mask; (5) a valveless N95 mask; and (6) a valved N95 mask. RESULTS: All mask types reduced the size of the contaminated region significantly. The percentage reduction in the cross-sectional area of the contaminated region for the same mask types on different subjects revealed by normalized data suggests that the fit of a mask plays an important role. CONCLUSIONS: No significant difference in the spread of coughed air was found between the use of a single surgical mask or a double surgical mask. Cloth masks may be effective, depending on the quality of the cloth. Valved N95 masks exclusively protect the user. The fit of a mask is an important factor to minimize the contaminated region.