Essential Components of an Interstitial Lung Disease Clinic: Results from a Delphi Survey and Patient Focus Group Analysis

Graney, Bridget A.; He, Christophe; Marll, Michael; Matson, Scott; Bianchi, Pauline; Cosgrove, Gregory P.; Lee, Joyce S.; Abrencillo, Rodeo; Bascom, Rebecca; Scholand, Mary Beth; Bhatt, Nitin; Case, Amy; Chaudhary, Sachin; Culver, Daniel; Danoff, Sonye; Desai, Alpa; Dilling, Daniel; Glazer, Craig; Gulati, Mridu; Gupta, Nishant; Hamblin, Mark; Hamzeh, Nabeel; Huie, Tristan; Kim, Hyun; King, Christopher; Kreider, Maryl; Lacamera, Peter; Lancaster, Lisa; Luckhardt, Tracy; Mageto, Yolanda; Kottman, Robert Matthew; McCormick, James; Mehrad, Borna; Menon, Prema; Montesi, Sydney; Mooney, Joshua; Moore, Doug; Moua, Teng; Nambiar, Anoop; Oldham, Justin; Patel, Divya; Paul, Tessy; Perez, Rafael; Podolanczuk, Anna; Ramaswamy, Murali; Roe, David; Saad, Mohamed; Sandbo, Nathan; Schaumberg, Thomas; Schmidt, Shelley; Shea, Barry; Shifren, Adrian; Strek, Mary; Thavarajah, Krishna; Todd, Nevins; Veeraraghavan, Srihari; Weight, Stephen; Wolters, Paul; Zibrak, Joseph

Background Management of patients with interstitial lung disease (ILD) requires subspecialized, comprehensive, multidisciplinary care. The Pulmonary Fibrosis Foundation established the Care Center Network (CCN) in 2013 with identified criteria to become a designated CCN site. Despite these criteria, the essential components of an ILD clinic remain unknown. Research Questions How are ILD clinics within the CCN structured? What are the essential components of an ILD clinic according to ILD physician experts, patients, and caregivers? Study Design and Methods This study had 3 components. First, all 68 CCN sites were surveyed to determine the characteristics of their current ILD clinics. Second, an online, three-round modified Delphi survey was conducted between October and December 2019 with 48 ILD experts participating in total. Items for round one were generated using expert interviews. During rounds 1 and 2, experts rated the importance of each item on a 5-point Likert scale. The a priori threshold for consensus was greater than 75% of experts rating an item as important or very important. In round 3, experts graded items that met consensus and ranked items deemed essential for an ILD clinic. Third, ILD patient and caregiver focus groups were conducted and analyzed for content to determine their perspectives of an ideal ILD clinic. Results Forty items across four categories (members, infrastructure, resources and multidisciplinary conference) achieved consensus as essential to an ILD clinic. Patient and caregiver focus groups identified three major themes: comprehensive, patient-centered medical care; expanded access to care; and comprehensive support for living and coping with ILD. Interpretation The essential components of an ILD clinic are well-aligned between physician experts and patients. Future research can use these findings to evaluate the impact of these components on patient outcomes and inform best-practices for ILD clinics throughout the world.